SymfonyRuntime CVE-2024-50340 Patch Bypass: Web Requests Can Still Set APP_ENV/APP_DEBUG via parse_str/SAPI Argv Mismatch
The advisory, in context
Description
CVE-2024-50340 (GHSA-x8vp-gf4q-mw5j) addressed an issue where, with register_argc_argv=On, a crafted query string let an unauthenticated GET change the kernel environment and debug flag by feeding --env/--no-debug through $_SERVER['argv']. The fix shipped in symfony/runtime 5.4.46 / 6.4.14 / 7.1.7 gated the argv read on empty($_GET) as a proxy for "is this a CLI invocation".
That proxy is unsafe: parse_str() (which builds $_GET) and the web SAPI (which builds $_SERVER['argv'] from the raw query when register_argc_argv=On) do not agree on every input, so an attacker can craft a query that leaves $_GET empty while $_SERVER['argv'] carries the attacker's flags. SymfonyRuntime::getInput() then parses them, restoring the exact primitive CVE-2024-50340 was meant to prevent.
Preconditions and impact match the original CVE: web SAPI, register_argc_argv=On, app booted through symfony/runtime; from an unauthenticated GET an attacker can flip APP_ENV and toggle APP_DEBUG.
Resolution
SymfonyRuntime now gates the argv read on isset($_SERVER['QUERY_STRING']) rather than on empty($_GET). QUERY_STRING is the same input the SAPI uses to build argv, so the security check and the thing it protects no longer parse different sources. Worker SAPIs (FrankenPHP / RoadRunner / Swoole) keep working because the runtime constructor runs once at boot when QUERY_STRING is unset.
The patch for this issue is available here for branch 5.4.
Credits
SymfonyRuntime would like to thank 0xEr3n for reporting the issue and Nicolas Grekas for providing the fix.
Affected packages
Start with the recorded fix for your release branch. Check your installed version and test compatibility before upgrading. Fixing this advisory does not rule out other vulnerabilities in the release.
From 5.4.46 before 5.4.52
Fixed in 5.4.52
1 explicitly affected versions
v5.4.46
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "5.4.46"
},
{
"fixed": "5.4.52"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v5.4.46"
]
}From 6.4.14 before 6.4.40
Fixed in 6.4.40
6 explicitly affected versions
v6.4.14, v6.4.22, v6.4.23, v6.4.24, v6.4.26, v6.4.30
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "6.4.14"
},
{
"fixed": "6.4.40"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v6.4.14",
"v6.4.22",
"v6.4.23",
"v6.4.24",
"v6.4.26",
"v6.4.30"
]
}From 7.1.7 before 7.4.12
Fixed in 7.4.12
20 explicitly affected versions
v7.1.7, v7.2.0, v7.2.0-BETA1, v7.2.0-BETA2, v7.2.0-RC1, v7.2.3, v7.2.7, v7.2.8, v7.3.0, v7.3.0-BETA1, v7.3.0-RC1, v7.3.1, v7.3.4, v7.3.8, v7.4.0, v7.4.0-BETA1, v7.4.0-BETA2, v7.4.0-RC1, v7.4.1, v7.4.8
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "7.1.7"
},
{
"fixed": "7.4.12"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v7.1.7",
"v7.2.0",
"v7.2.0-BETA1",
"v7.2.0-BETA2",
"v7.2.0-RC1",
"v7.2.3",
"v7.2.7",
"v7.2.8",
"v7.3.0",
"v7.3.0-BETA1",
"v7.3.0-RC1",
"v7.3.1",
"v7.3.4",
"v7.3.8",
"v7.4.0",
"v7.4.0-BETA1",
"v7.4.0-BETA2",
"v7.4.0-RC1",
"v7.4.1",
"v7.4.8"
]
}From 8.0.0 before 8.0.12
Fixed in 8.0.12
3 explicitly affected versions
v8.0.0, v8.0.1, v8.0.8
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "8.0.0"
},
{
"fixed": "8.0.12"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v8.0.0",
"v8.0.1",
"v8.0.8"
]
}From 5.4.46 before 5.4.52
Fixed in 5.4.52
6 explicitly affected versions
v5.4.46, v5.4.47, v5.4.48, v5.4.49, v5.4.50, v5.4.51
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "5.4.46"
},
{
"fixed": "5.4.52"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v5.4.46",
"v5.4.47",
"v5.4.48",
"v5.4.49",
"v5.4.50",
"v5.4.51"
]
}From 6.4.14 before 6.4.40
Fixed in 6.4.40
26 explicitly affected versions
v6.4.14, v6.4.15, v6.4.16, v6.4.17, v6.4.18, v6.4.19, v6.4.20, v6.4.21, v6.4.22, v6.4.23, v6.4.24, v6.4.25, v6.4.26, v6.4.27, v6.4.28, v6.4.29, v6.4.30, v6.4.31, v6.4.32, v6.4.33, v6.4.34, v6.4.35, v6.4.36, v6.4.37, v6.4.38, v6.4.39
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "6.4.14"
},
{
"fixed": "6.4.40"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v6.4.14",
"v6.4.15",
"v6.4.16",
"v6.4.17",
"v6.4.18",
"v6.4.19",
"v6.4.20",
"v6.4.21",
"v6.4.22",
"v6.4.23",
"v6.4.24",
"v6.4.25",
"v6.4.26",
"v6.4.27",
"v6.4.28",
"v6.4.29",
"v6.4.30",
"v6.4.31",
"v6.4.32",
"v6.4.33",
"v6.4.34",
"v6.4.35",
"v6.4.36",
"v6.4.37",
"v6.4.38",
"v6.4.39"
]
}From 7.1.7 before 7.4.12
Fixed in 7.4.12
50 explicitly affected versions
v7.1.10, v7.1.11, v7.1.7, v7.1.8, v7.1.9, v7.2.0, v7.2.0-BETA1, v7.2.0-BETA2, v7.2.0-RC1, v7.2.1, v7.2.2, v7.2.3, v7.2.4, v7.2.5, v7.2.6, v7.2.7, v7.2.8, v7.2.9, v7.3.0, v7.3.0-BETA1, v7.3.0-BETA2, v7.3.0-RC1, v7.3.1, v7.3.10, v7.3.11, v7.3.2, v7.3.3, v7.3.4, v7.3.5, v7.3.6, v7.3.7, v7.3.8, v7.3.9, v7.4.0, v7.4.0-BETA1, v7.4.0-BETA2, v7.4.0-RC1, v7.4.0-RC2, v7.4.0-RC3, v7.4.1, v7.4.10, v7.4.11, v7.4.2, v7.4.3, v7.4.4, v7.4.5, v7.4.6, v7.4.7, v7.4.8, v7.4.9
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "7.1.7"
},
{
"fixed": "7.4.12"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v7.1.10",
"v7.1.11",
"v7.1.7",
"v7.1.8",
"v7.1.9",
"v7.2.0",
"v7.2.0-BETA1",
"v7.2.0-BETA2",
"v7.2.0-RC1",
"v7.2.1",
"v7.2.2",
"v7.2.3",
"v7.2.4",
"v7.2.5",
"v7.2.6",
"v7.2.7",
"v7.2.8",
"v7.2.9",
"v7.3.0",
"v7.3.0-BETA1",
"v7.3.0-BETA2",
"v7.3.0-RC1",
"v7.3.1",
"v7.3.10",
"v7.3.11",
"v7.3.2",
"v7.3.3",
"v7.3.4",
"v7.3.5",
"v7.3.6",
"v7.3.7",
"v7.3.8",
"v7.3.9",
"v7.4.0",
"v7.4.0-BETA1",
"v7.4.0-BETA2",
"v7.4.0-RC1",
"v7.4.0-RC2",
"v7.4.0-RC3",
"v7.4.1",
"v7.4.10",
"v7.4.11",
"v7.4.2",
"v7.4.3",
"v7.4.4",
"v7.4.5",
"v7.4.6",
"v7.4.7",
"v7.4.8",
"v7.4.9"
]
}From 8.0.0 before 8.0.12
Fixed in 8.0.12
12 explicitly affected versions
v8.0.0, v8.0.1, v8.0.10, v8.0.11, v8.0.2, v8.0.3, v8.0.4, v8.0.5, v8.0.6, v8.0.7, v8.0.8, v8.0.9
View affected-version evidence
{
"ranges": [
{
"events": [
{
"introduced": "8.0.0"
},
{
"fixed": "8.0.12"
}
],
"type": "ECOSYSTEM"
}
],
"versions": [
"v8.0.0",
"v8.0.1",
"v8.0.10",
"v8.0.11",
"v8.0.2",
"v8.0.3",
"v8.0.4",
"v8.0.5",
"v8.0.6",
"v8.0.7",
"v8.0.8",
"v8.0.9"
]
}